Pillar 3a comparison Switzerland 2026: Best providers & costs
Over the years, fees can cost you a six-figure sum.
Why the provider matters
With pillar 3a, you do not just pay in money, you also choose how it is invested. A bank gives you 0.1 to 0.5% interest. An ETF-based provider like VIAC or Finpension gives you a 4 to 7% return, but with fluctuations.
Over 30 years, the difference between 0.5% and 6% interest means more than double at the end. CHF 7'000 per year becomes about CHF 220'000 at 0.5%, and about CHF 560'000 at 6%.
The fee example: CHF 100'000 over 30 years
It becomes even clearer with a one-off amount. Let's take CHF 100'000, invested over 30 years at a gross return of 4% per year. Nothing new is paid in; the only variable is the provider's annual fee:
| Annual fee | Net return | Final wealth after 30 years |
|---|---|---|
| 0.5% e.g. Finpension | 3.5% | CHF 280'700 |
| 1.0% e.g. bank fund | 3.0% | CHF 242'700 |
| 1.5% e.g. insurance | 2.5% | CHF 209'800 |
The providers compared
| Provider | Type | Fees/year | Strategy | App |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VIAC Best return | Fintech | 0.38-0.52% | ETF ( global) | Very good |
| Finpension Cheapest | Fintech | 0.21-0.43% | ETF (free choice) | Good |
| Frankly Best app | ZKB | 0.42-0.55% | ETF (accumulating) | Very good |
| PostFinance 3a | Bank | 0.25-1.00% | Bank account + funds | Good |
| UBS 3a | Bank | 0.50-1.50% | Bank account + funds | Average |
| Raiffeisen 3a | Bank | 0.25-1.00% | Bank account + funds | Good |
| AXA / Swiss Life | Insurance | 1.00-2.00% | Insurance policy | Average |
1. VIAC: the ETF pioneers
VIAC was the first Swiss provider to offer pillar 3a as an ETF savings plan. Today it is one of the most popular fintech 3a providers.
- Very low fees (from 0.38%)
- ETF strategies from Global Vision Capital
- Several strategies to choose from (100% equities, defensive, etc.)
- Very intuitive app
- Limited ETF selection (ready-made strategies)
- No bank account function
Who it is for: Anyone who wants to save simply, cheaply and based on ETFs. Set it and forget it.
2. Finpension: the cheapest
Finpension offers the lowest fees on the Swiss market. In return, you can put together your ETFs yourself.
- Lowest fees (from 0.21%)
- Free choice of ETFs from a long list
- Build your own portfolio
- App not as polished as VIAC or Frankly
- Fewer guided strategies
Who it is for: Anyone who knows what they want and is looking for the lowest fees. People who like to decide for themselves.
3. Frankly: from ZKB
Frankly is the digital 3a solution from Zürcher Kantonalbank. It offers ETF savings plans with a good app.
- Very good, polished app
- Security of a cantonal bank (state guarantee)
- ETF + bank account option
- Slightly higher fees than VIAC/Finpension
- Smaller ETF selection than Finpension
Who it is for: Anyone who wants the security of a bank but is still looking for ETF returns.
4. Banks (UBS, PostFinance, Raiffeisen)
The traditional banks offer pillar 3a as a bank account (0.1-0.5% interest) or as a fund solution (more expensive, limited choice).
- Everything at the same bank
- Bank account option for safe deposits
- Higher fees for fund solutions
- Less flexible ETF selection
- Lower returns than pure ETF providers
Who it is for: Anyone who wants everything at one bank and does not want a separate app.
5. Insurers (AXA, Swiss Life)
- Death cover included
- High fees (1-2% per year)
- Not very flexible, money is tied up
- Return usually lower than ETF
- Complicated payout
What does the provider cost over 30 years?
Fees have an effect through compound interest. Here is an example: CHF 7'000 per year, 30 years, 6% gross return:
| Provider | Fees/year | Final wealth | Loss due to fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Finpension | 0.25% | CHF 553'000 | - |
| VIAC | 0.45% | CHF 524'000 | CHF 29'000 |
| Frankly | 0.50% | CHF 517'000 | CHF 36'000 |
| UBS funds | 1.20% | CHF 430'000 | CHF 123'000 |
| Insurance | 1.80% | CHF 365'000 | CHF 188'000 |
Our conclusion
| If you... | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| want to start simply | VIAC: app, ETF, low cost |
| want the lowest fees | Finpension: 0.21% |
| want a bank behind it | Frankly (ZKB) |
| want to play it safe (no stock market) | Bank 3a account (0% fee, but 0% return) |
| want everything at one bank | PostFinance or Raiffeisen |
Pro tip: several 3a accounts
Open 2 to 3 accounts with different providers. Not for the fees, but for the payout. When paid out, each 3a account is taxed separately. Three accounts, paid out over three years, means three low tax brackets instead of one big one.
For example: one account with VIAC (ETF), one with Finpension (ETF), one with a bank (security). That way you diversify providers and optimise the payout.
CasaFin for your retirement savings
Bills, receipts and deadlines in one app. Pay for one year, use it permanently.
See the offer or try it free for 14 days